Another Kidnapping
1844, by William Wells Brown, describes Brown’s encounter with an African American
couple, Mr. and Mrs. Wilkinson, as he travels through Georgetown on his way to
Mount Pleasant Ohio. The Wilkinson’s tell Brown about the men who came into
their home, beat them, and kidnapped their fifteen year old son. The kidnappers
quickly traveled over the river to Virginia and Mr. Wilkinson knows his son is
gone forever. Brown says, “One of the villains was recognized, but it was by a
colored man, and the colored people have not thee right of their oath in this
state. This villain will go unwhipped of Justice” (442 Brown).
Reading this added to my understanding the true conflict
between the North and the South. The setting took place in the North where this
African American family was free to live in a non-slave state. Yet, people from
the South were able to kidnap those from the North and turn them into slaves. It
seemed through Brown’s use of characterization and tone the family in the story
had really given up hope only after a day and had come to realize that they
would never see their son again, even though someone had identified one of the
kidnappers. Miss. Ophelia’s character in Uncle Tom’s Cabin seemed to
portray how against slavery Northerners were. Talking about slavery Miss.
Ophelia says, “I wouldn’t have it, for a thousand worlds. You ought to educate
your slaves, and treat them like reasonable creatures,- like immortal creatures
that you’ve got to stand before the bar of God with”(161 Stowe). If this was
true why wouldn’t they have laws in place that would help stop Southerners from
kidnapping Northern African American’s and turning them into slaves, especially
since there were laws like the Great Compromise and the Fugitive Slave Act
which both supported slavery and were there for the South to benefit from.
Yet, on the other hand whites from the North still disliked African
American’s even if they did not support slavery. Miss. Ophelia portrayed this
when she interacted with Topsy. Topsy describes how Miss. Ophelia feels about
her saying, “No; she can’t bar me, ‘cause I’m a nigger!- she’d ‘s soon have a toad
touch her” (258 Stowe). Miss. Ophelia seems hypocritical since she does not
support slavery yet treats slaves worse than her cousin, who is a slave owner.
Works Cited
Brown, William W. "Another Kidnapping 1844." (1969): 442. Print.
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Ed. Elizabeth Ammons. New York: W.W. Norton, 1994. Print.
Works Cited
Brown, William W. "Another Kidnapping 1844." (1969): 442. Print.
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Ed. Elizabeth Ammons. New York: W.W. Norton, 1994. Print.
I like your observations about the hypocrisy within Ophelia. Maybe it would be better understood if taken from one of today's issues. Take gay marriage for instance. Many people believe that everyone should have to right to do as they wish as long as it isn't harming anyone else in the process, thus they themselves "support" gay marriage. But while this person may feel that all humans should have rights, that doesn't also mean that they agree with gay marriage, and as a result might treat these people differently from what they consider to be "okay". It's a tricky thing to understand, and I'm not saying that I completely understand it myself, but sometimes it's helpful to put it into today's perspective. Also as an add on, I'd like to say that I like your criticism of Ophelia, because to me it seems that Stowe's purpose for her at the end is to convey that Ophelia is how all people should be, because she sort of changes, but it's good to look back and understand how far her character has come; just as readers from the 1800's might have to understand how far of a journey it is going to be for them to possibly change their minds on the subject.
ReplyDeleteI agree, I think it really helps to put it in a modern perspective so it is easier to relate to and I like the example of gay marriage because it is a very controversial issue with many sides to it.
DeleteI thought it was very interesting to read that whites in the north still didn't like African Americans who lived in the north even if they didn't support slavery. I also like the modern aspect you talked about. And how this reading really points out the hatred between the north and the south.
ReplyDeleteYes, I really thought it was interesting to see the differences between the north and south.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI agree with Stacy on how it is interesting, to read that white in the north didn't like African Americans. In my opinion people don't like things that are different. Black is different then white. Then another part of me wants to think the whites didn't want to get involved or start controversy with the south, so they just went along to make the southern whites happy. Good post!
ReplyDeleteI think both of you'r opinions are true, how some people do not like things that are different and others don't want to start a war with the south.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
Delete